12 Best Mail-Order Steaks You Won’t Regret Ordering

If you’re ordering mail-order steaks, you’ll want options with proven quality and reliable aging.

The lineup includes Nebraska Star Beef Prestige NY strip sets, Omaha Steaks Filet Mignons, USDA Choice NY Strips, 6 oz Filet Mignons, and versatile Grumpy Butcher gift baskets.

Plus, there’s premium sirloin and Rastelli’s Black Angus.

With vacuum sealing, dry ice, and clear storage guidance, you get freshness and convenience.

Want to know which offer best fits your occasion and budget? You’ll find it here.

Nebraska Star Beef Prestige Steaks – 12 NY Strips

Experience the convenience of restaurant-quality steaks delivered straight to your home with Nebraska Star Beef Prestige Steaks – 12 NY Strips. These steaks provide a practical way to enjoy premium beef without the hassle of sourcing or preparation. Each 8-ounce NY strip is carefully selected for its excellent marbling, ensuring rich flavor and tenderness every time.

The steaks undergo a wet-aging process that naturally enhances their texture and depth of taste. This method makes them easier to cook to perfection while maintaining a juicy, robust profile. Vacuum-sealed packaging locks in freshness, simplifying storage and extending shelf life without compromising quality.

Ideal for a variety of occasions, these steaks adapt well to both casual dinners and special events. The signature seasoning subtly elevates the natural beef taste, adding a gourmet touch that requires no additional preparation. This makes them a versatile choice for busy households or anyone seeking a refined meal with minimal effort.

For maintenance, simply thaw the vacuum-sealed steaks in the refrigerator and cook to your preferred doneness. Their consistent size and portion make meal planning straightforward, although the set quantity may exceed the needs of smaller households. The exclusive focus on NY strip cuts suits fans of this popular steak style but limits variety.

Best for: Home cooks and meat lovers wanting convenient access to premium NY strip steaks with consistent quality and flavor for elegant meals or gifts.

What We Like:

• Hand-selected from grass-fed cattle, ensuring premium marbling and flavor.
• Wet-aging process enhances tenderness and taste.
• Vacuum-sealed packaging preserves freshness effectively.
• Signature seasoning adds a gourmet touch with minimal effort.
• Consistent portion sizes simplify meal planning and cooking.

Specification:

Omaha Steaks Filet Mignons 4 (5 oz)

Omaha Steaks Filet Mignons 4 (5 oz) offer an exceptional way to enjoy premium, restaurant-quality filets in the comfort of your own home. These steaks are thicker, center-cut filets that deliver a tender and indulgent eating experience. Their natural aging process enhances both flavor and texture, making every bite deeply satisfying.

Each filet is hand-selected and USDA Certified Tender, trimmed lean for a clean, steakhouse-style taste. The steaks come individually vacuum-sealed, preserving freshness and making storage simple. This packaging also ensures that the filets maintain their quality until you’re ready to cook.

Whether you prefer grilling, pan-searing, or roasting, these filets adapt well to different cooking methods. Their thickness allows for a juicy, tender interior while developing a flavorful crust. The pack size suits small family meals or intimate dinners but may require multiple packs for larger groups.

Best for: fans of premium, restaurant-style filet mignons at home who want thicker, center-cut steaks with tenderness and versatility for grilling, pan-searing, or roasting.

What We Like:

• Thick, center-cut steaks for a tender, indulgent bite
• Naturally aged at least 30 days to enhance flavor and tenderness
• Individually vacuum-sealed for freshness and easy storage

Specification:

10 (8 oz.) New York Strip Steaks

Experience the rich, authentic flavor of USDA Choice New York Strip Steaks, expertly hand-cut into 8 oz. portions. These steaks are designed to provide consistent, high-quality cuts that simplify meal planning and portion control. Each steak delivers pure beef taste without any additives or solutions, ensuring a natural dining experience.

Carefully packaged to maintain freshness, these steaks arrive individually sealed, making storage and handling effortless. The custom packaging helps lock in flavor and quality, while the inclusion of dry ice and gel packs preserves freshness during shipment. This thoughtful design means less waste and more enjoyment.

Ideal for grilling or pan-searing, these steaks suit a variety of cooking methods. Their 8 oz. size offers versatility but may require pairing for larger appetites or group meals. Proper thawing and cooking are essential to maximize tenderness and flavor.

Originating from USA-raised cattle and hand-cut in Louisville, Kentucky since 1946, these steaks reflect a longstanding commitment to quality. Their consistent size and additive-free nature make them a reliable choice for home cooks and grill enthusiasts.

Best for: Home cooks and grill enthusiasts seeking premium, portion-controlled New York Strip steaks from a trusted USA-raised source.

What We Like:

• Individually sealed for freshness and easy portion control
• 100% USA-raised beef with no additives or solutions
• Hand-cut by experienced butchers ensuring consistent quality
• Packaging designed to maintain flavor and freshness during transit

Specification:

10 (6 oz.) Filet Mignon Steaks

Our 6 oz. Filet Mignon Steaks offer a premium dining experience with perfectly portioned, hand-cut steaks that deliver consistent quality. Each steak is individually sealed to lock in freshness, so you can enjoy tender, juicy cuts with every order. This packaging method also reduces waste and keeps the steaks ready for quick preparation.

Designed for convenience, these steaks come packaged using dry ice and gel packs to maintain optimal temperature during transit. This ensures your filet mignon arrives in peak condition, preserving its delicate texture and rich flavor. The careful packaging also simplifies storage and handling once received.

Ideal for both weeknight meals and special occasions, these steaks provide a restaurant-quality experience at home. Their melt-in-your-mouth tenderness makes them a standout choice for those who appreciate fine dining without the hassle. The consistent 6 oz. size offers portion control suitable for balanced meals.

While these filet mignons offer exceptional quality, they may require careful handling upon arrival due to the dry ice packaging. Additionally, the 6 oz. portion size might not suit those with larger appetites or specific serving preferences. Despite these considerations, their premium flavor and convenience remain unmatched.

Best for: Home cooks seeking high-quality, tender filet mignon steaks delivered fresh and ready for effortless preparation.

What We Like:

• Individually sealed steaks ensure freshness with every cut
• Hand-cut portions provide consistent thickness and tenderness
• Packaging with dry ice and gel packs preserves quality during shipping
• Suitable size for controlled portions and easy meal planning

Specification:

Grumpy Butcher 8 Steaks Premium Gift Basket

The Grumpy Butcher 8 Steaks Premium Gift Basket offers a versatile selection of high-quality steaks, perfect for elevating any meal or celebration. This carefully curated set includes a mix of NY Strip, Ribeye, and Filet Mignon cuts, providing options that cater to various taste preferences and cooking styles.

Each steak is made from top-tier USDA Prime or Angus Choice beef, ensuring exceptional tenderness and rich flavor. The beef is sourced exclusively from the best 2% of U.S. cattle, delivering a premium eating experience without fillers or by-products.

Flash freezing locks in freshness and marbling, allowing you to store the steaks conveniently until you’re ready to cook. The pasture-raised origins from Mid-West ranches reflect ethical farming practices, giving you confidence in the quality and sustainability of your meat.

This gift basket is designed not only for gifting but also for hosts who want to impress guests with a variety of top-cut steaks. Proper thawing and refrigeration are recommended to maintain optimal taste and texture.

Best for: gift-givers and hosts seeking a premium assortment of diverse, high-quality steaks for special occasions or gatherings.

What We Like:

• Diverse selection of NY Strip, Ribeye, and Filet Mignon cuts
• Premium USDA Prime or Angus Choice beef for superior flavor
• Expertly cut and flash frozen for convenience and freshness
• Pasture-raised sourcing ensures ethical and quality meat

Specification:

Omaha Steaks Deluxe Ribeye Gift Box Set

The Omaha Steaks Deluxe Ribeye Gift Box offers a versatile and convenient way to enjoy a premium grilling experience. Perfectly curated, this set includes a variety of meats and sides that cater to diverse tastes and simplify meal preparation. Whether for a special occasion or a casual gathering, it brings everything you need in one thoughtfully designed package.

Each item is individually portioned and ready to cook, allowing for easy meal planning and reducing food waste. The bacon-wrapped ribeyes and juicy burgers deliver rich flavors, while the potatoes au gratin and caramel apple tartlets add satisfying sides and desserts. The included seasoning jar enhances taste without requiring extra pantry staples.

Storage is hassle-free with options to refrigerate or freeze until needed, maintaining freshness and quality. The elegant ready-to-gift box presentation eliminates the need for additional wrapping, making it an excellent choice for gifting or personal enjoyment. This set balances variety with convenience, ideal for those who appreciate fine meats and complementary sides.

However, its meat-centric selection may not suit vegetarian preferences, and the seasoning provided caters to specific flavor profiles. Portion sizes are generous, which might be more than needed for smaller households or single meals.

Best for: Meat lovers and grilling enthusiasts seeking a diverse, ready-to-gift assortment for special occasions.

What We Like:

• Wide variety of meats and sides in one package
• Convenient, ready-to-cook individual portions
• Elegant gift-ready packaging
• Easy to store with refrigeration or freezing options
• Includes a seasoning jar to enhance flavor

Specification:

Grumpy Butcher Grass-Fed Sirloin & Filet Steak Gift Box

Elevate your steak experience with the Grumpy Butcher Grass-Fed Sirloin & Filet Steak Gift Box. This carefully curated selection offers lean, premium cuts that bring exceptional flavor and tenderness without any hassle. Designed for those who appreciate quality and convenience, these steaks arrive vacuum-sealed to maintain freshness and ready to cook straight away.

Each gift box contains one Top Sirloin and one Large Filet Mignon, both sourced from trusted Midwestern ranches where cattle are pasture-fed with humane practices. This method promotes superior marbling and a richer, more natural taste, making every bite deeply satisfying. The steaks are aged and expertly cut to ensure even cooking and a buttery texture.

Presented in an elegant, ready-to-gift box, this set is ideal for special occasions such as birthdays and holidays. You can also add a personal note to make your gift more meaningful, combining convenience with a thoughtful touch.

While the box includes just two premium steaks, it focuses on quality over quantity, catering to steak lovers who want the best grass-fed beef. Seasonal availability reflects the natural cycles of the Midwest ranches, ensuring freshness and authenticity.

Best for: steak enthusiasts seeking premium, lean, grass-fed beef delivered in an elegant gift-ready presentation with personalized options.

What We Like:

• USDA Choice or Prime Angus steaks with rich flavor and tender texture
• Vacuum-sealed packaging preserves freshness and simplifies storage
• Grass-fed, pasture-raised beef from trusted Midwestern ranches
• Elegant gift box with optional personalized note for special occasions
• Over 30 years of craftsmanship and quality assurance from Grumpy Butcher

Specification

Premium Tenderloin Filet Mignon Medallions, 16 Count

Premium Tenderloin Filet Mignon Medallions offer an effortless way to enjoy exceptional steak quality at home. These 16 medallions, each weighing about 2 ounces, are perfectly portioned for quick cooking without sacrificing tenderness or flavor. The steaks are aged up to 28 days, enhancing their natural richness and texture.

Each medallion is carefully trimmed and flash-frozen to preserve freshness and lock in taste. The vacuum-sealed packaging keeps the meat protected, making storage simple and convenient. This design helps maintain the steak’s premium quality until you’re ready to cook.

Preparation is straightforward with included guidance that supports all skill levels. A complimentary cooking guide and Original Steak Seasoning packet provide useful tips and enhance flavor, allowing you to confidently create a restaurant-quality meal. Proper cooking is essential to avoid overcooking due to the tender texture.

These tenderloin medallions are ideal for those seeking high-quality beef in manageable portions, offering both convenience and gourmet results at home.

Best for: Home cooks wanting premium tenderloin steaks portioned for easy, quick preparation and rich flavor.

What We Like:

• Ultra-tender tenderloin aged up to 28 days for superior flavor
• Convenient 16-count, vacuum-sealed packaging for freshness and easy storage
• Comes with a detailed cooking guide and seasoning packet for enhanced taste
• Flash-frozen to lock in quality and simplify meal preparation

Specification:

Grumpy Butcher 6-Steak Supreme Sampler Gift Box

Grumpy Butcher 6-Steak Supreme Sampler Gift Box delivers a premium dining experience right to your doorstep. Designed for steak enthusiasts who crave high-quality cuts, this sampler offers a selection of six carefully chosen steaks, ideal for home cooking or special occasions. The combination of Top Sirloin and Filet Mignon ensures a balance of rich flavor and tender texture.

Each steak is sourced from grassfed, pasture-raised Midwestern ranches, reflecting a commitment to ethical farming practices. The beef is USDA Choice or Prime Angus, aged to enhance tenderness and flavor. Vacuum-sealed packaging maintains freshness and simplifies storage, making it easy to enjoy restaurant-quality steaks without the hassle.

This gift box is perfect for those who appreciate convenience combined with gourmet quality. The ready-to-gift presentation includes an option for personalized notes, making it a thoughtful and elegant choice for celebrations or gifts. Proper refrigeration and grilling or pan-searing will bring out the best in these lean cuts.

Best for: Steak lovers wanting premium, grassfed sirloin and filet mignon delivered in a convenient, gift-ready box.

What We Like:

• Expertly aged USDA Choice or Prime Angus beef ensures superior flavor and tenderness.
• Vacuum-sealed packaging preserves freshness and simplifies storage.
• Combination of four Top Sirloin and two Filet Mignon steaks offers variety and quality.
• Ready-to-gift box with optional personalized note enhances presentation.

Specification:

Premium Top Sirloin Steak, 8 Count, 5 oz Each

Experience the convenience of restaurant-quality steak right at home with these Premium Top Sirloin Steaks. Each steak is carefully aged up to 28 days to enhance tenderness and flavor, solving the common problem of dry or tough cuts. The steaks arrive in perfectly sized 5-ounce portions, making meal planning simple and efficient.

Each cut is USDA-inspected, flash-frozen, and individually vacuum-sealed to lock in freshness and prevent freezer burn. This packaging design allows for easy storage and quick thawing when you’re ready to cook. The deep marbling ensures juicy, tender steaks that deliver rich flavor with every bite.

Included with your steaks is a free seasoning pack and detailed cooking instructions, guiding you step-by-step to grill or broil your steak perfectly. This support eliminates guesswork and helps both beginners and experienced cooks achieve consistent results.

Maintenance is straightforward: keep the steaks frozen until use, thaw safely in the refrigerator, and follow the provided cooking tips. While the 5-ounce portions are ideal for individual servings, larger appetites may require multiple steaks per meal.

Best for: Home cooks and families seeking convenient, premium top sirloin steaks with guided cooking support.

What We Like:

• Deep marbling for tender, juicy flavor and enhanced dining experience
• Individually vacuum-sealed, flash-frozen USDA-inspected cuts for lasting freshness
• Includes a free seasoning pack and easy-to-follow cooking instructions
• Convenient 5-ounce portions ideal for precise meal planning

Specification:

Rastelli’s Black Angus Sirloin Steaks (8 ct)

Rastelli’s Black Angus Sirloin Steaks bring premium quality straight to your kitchen. These steaks are designed to deliver a restaurant-grade experience without the hassle of dining out. Each 6 oz steak is carefully prepared to ensure consistent tenderness and flavor for every meal.

The steaks undergo a wet aging process for 45 days, which enhances their natural juiciness and tenderness. This method helps break down muscle fibers, making the meat easier to cook and enjoy. Each steak is hand-trimmed and vacuum sealed individually, preserving freshness and simplifying storage.

Included is a 1 oz Signature Seasoning Packet, giving you an effortless way to enhance the natural flavors right from the start. These sirloin steaks are versatile enough to grill, slice into salads, cube for stews, or pair with seafood for surf and turf dishes.

Maintaining freshness is made simple with individual packaging, allowing you to thaw only what you need. This product fits well into meal planning for home chefs seeking convenience without sacrificing quality.

Best for: Home cooks and food enthusiasts wanting premium, versatile sirloin steaks delivered fresh and ready for various recipes.

What We Like:

• Wet-aged 45 days for superior tenderness and flavor
• Individually vacuum sealed to lock in freshness and ease portioning
• Hand-trimmed for consistent quality and presentation
• Includes signature seasoning to simplify preparation

Specification:

Grumpy Butcher 8-Steak Full House Gift Set

The Grumpy Butcher 8-Steak Full House Gift Set offers a versatile selection of premium beef cuts designed to elevate any meal or occasion. This set includes a carefully balanced variety of ribeye, filet mignon, and top sirloin steaks, providing a range of flavors and textures that satisfy diverse tastes. Each steak is hand-cut from USDA-Choice or higher Angus beef, ensuring consistent quality and tenderness.

Vacuum-sealed and flash-frozen, the steaks arrive ready for convenient storage and long-lasting freshness. This packaging method locks in the natural juices, so you can enjoy restaurant-quality tenderness right at home. The included reusable gel packs maintain the cold chain during delivery, making it easy to store the steaks in your freezer without compromising quality.

Whether you are preparing a special dinner, hosting a backyard BBQ, or searching for a refined gift, this set covers multiple needs. The variety of cuts allows for flexible cooking methods, though some steaks may require different preparation times. This ensures a tailored grilling experience that can satisfy both casual and discerning eaters.

Best for: Grilling enthusiasts and gift-givers seeking a balanced, restaurant-quality beef assortment for entertaining, special occasions, or backyard BBQs.

What We Like:

• Balanced mix of ribeye, filet mignon, and top sirloin for varied taste and texture.
• Hand-cut, vacuum-sealed, and flash-frozen for optimal freshness and tenderness.
• Includes reusable gel packs for easy freezer storage and transport.
• Premium USDA-Choice or higher Angus beef guarantees consistent quality.

Specification:

Factors to Consider When Choosing Mail Order Steaks

When you’re picking out mail-order steaks, it’s a good idea to start by looking at where the meat comes from. Better farms and careful handling usually translate to tastier and more tender steaks. Next, think about the variety of cuts available so you can find something that suits how you like to cook. Don’t forget to consider how the steaks are aged, since that can really affect their texture and flavor. And finally, take a close look at the packaging to make sure the steaks stay fresh, plus check that the portion sizes are just right for your needs. That way, you’ll get exactly what you expect and can cook up a great meal without any hassle.

Meat Source Quality

Quality mail-order steak starts with where the cattle come from. You’ll notice premium cuts often come from grass-fed or pasture-raised cattle, known for superior flavor and tenderness.

USDA certification is a key indicator, ensuring the beef meets standards for tenderness and aging. The aging process, wet or dry, improves flavor and texture, with wet aging commonly used to preserve moisture and tenderness.

Sourcing from reputable farms that prioritize humane treatment and high-quality feed contributes to overall quality, yielding better marbling and richer flavor profiles. Transparency matters, so look for details about the ranch or farm the cattle come from to help you compare quality.

Informed choices stem from clear sourcing practices and consistent quality signals. It’s all about knowing where your steak comes from and trusting those who raise it right.

Cut Selection Variety

Choosing mail-order steaks means weighing cut options like ribeye, filet mignon, and NY strip, since each offers distinct flavors and textures. You’ll notice differences in tenderness, with filet mignon being the most tender, while ribeye brings rich marbling and bold flavor. The thickness of each cut matters, as thicker steaks need different cooking approaches than thinner ones.

To satisfy varied tastes, look for bundles or mixed-cut options that cover a meal or gathering. Consider how thickness and cut type influence your method—pan-searing, grilling, or finishing in the oven. Understanding grading, such as USDA Choice or Prime, helps you pick higher-quality options that deliver better taste and tenderness.

Aging Method Impact

Aging method can alter tenderness and flavor, so you’ll want to weigh wet aging versus dry aging before you order. Wet aging seals meat in vacuum bags and chills it, boosting tenderness and moisture while minimizing drying risk.

Dry aging hangs the beef in a controlled, cool environment, letting enzymes break down tissue for a concentrated flavor and distinct texture. It demands careful monitoring to avoid spoilage.

Aged beef commands higher prices due to time and resources, often spanning 14 to 60+ days, with longer aging amplifying complexity. Flavor shifts accompany the method: dry-aged tends toward nutty, earthy notes, while wet-aged usually keeps a fresher, beefier profile.

Your choice directly influences tenderness, flavor, and overall eating experience. So, consider the method as a quality factor when selecting mail-order steaks.

Packaging Freshness

When ordering steaks, how they’re packaged matters as much as how they’re aged. Proper packaging keeps freshness intact, with vacuum sealing locking in flavor and preventing spoilage. Dry ice or gel packs during shipping maintain the right temperature, ensuring you receive safe, high-quality meat.

Custom packaging solutions protect steaks from shifting and temperature swings, reducing damage during transit. Timely delivery matters, since longer shipping times can compromise quality and safety. So, choose vendors with efficient logistics.

A freshness guarantee adds another layer of confidence, signaling the provider’s commitment to preserving steak integrity from checkout to doorstep. In short, look for vacuum sealing, reliable temperature control, tailored packaging, prompt delivery, and a clear freshness promise when selecting mail-order options.

Portion Size Fit

Portion sizes matter because they directly shape cooking time, flavor, and meal planning. When you shop, note steaks range from about 5 oz to 14 oz, so pick sizes that fit your appetite and occasion. Smaller cuts cook faster and simpler, while larger ones demand more attention to reach the right doneness.

Decide if you want single servings or bigger steaks you can share for family meals or gatherings. For ease and less waste, choose individually vacuum-sealed portions, which simplify storage and prep. Match size to use—grilling for a barbecue, or recipes needing cubed beef—so you select the right steak for your culinary plan.

This alignment helps you enjoy ideal texture, flavor, and planning confidence. It’s all about picking what works best for you and your meal.

Price Per Steak

Choosing mail-order steaks isn’t just about the cut or size. It’s also about value. Price per steak varies with the cut, quality, and sourcing methods. For example, premium cuts like filet mignon cost more than sirloin.

When calculating price per steak, use total package weight divided by the number of steaks. This helps you gauge cost-effectiveness per serving. Bulk purchases often reduce the price per steak. That way, you can stock up without sacrificing quality.

Seasonal promotions and discounts can shift prices, so it pays to compare offers across suppliers before you buy. Also, consider value-added extras like seasoning packets or cooking guides. These can raise the overall price per steak but add useful perks.

Weigh these factors to find true value, not just the sticker price.

Shipping & Storage

Shipping and storage are critical when buying mail-order steaks. You want vacuum-sealed packaging with dry ice or gel packs to keep freshness and avoid spoilage during transit. Check that the seller offers expedited shipping options so steaks spend less time in transit, especially in warmer months.

Look for clear storage instructions, so you know whether to refrigerate or freeze upon arrival. Packaging should be designed to prevent freezer burn, safeguarding quality and taste over time. Also, evaluate the delivery schedule to guarantee you or someone you trust can receive the package.

Timely intake preserves meat texture and safety. By prioritizing these factors, you’ll minimize waste and maximize flavor from your mail-order steaks. It’s really about making sure your steak arrives just as delicious as you expect.

Frequently Asked Questions

How Long Do Mailed Steaks Stay Fresh During Transit?

In transit, mailed steaks stay freshest if you choose expedited shipping and dry ice. Expect about 2 to 5 days from ship date to arrival, depending on distance and carrier.

When you receive them, thaw in the fridge if needed, then cook promptly. If you don’t plan to cook soon, you can freeze them to preserve quality longer.

Always check the packing for coldness and use your best judgment on freshness once opened. It’s better to be cautious when it comes to meat safety!

Which Cut Best Fits Budget and Flavor Balance?

The ribeye hits the sweet spot of budget and flavor, giving you rich marbling without overshooting costs. You’ll often find comparable flavor in the NY strip, but ribeye delivers more tenderness per bite. About 20% of steak lovers rank ribeye as their top choice for value where flavor matters most, so you’ll feel satisfied without breaking the bank.

If you want lean, go for sirloin, but expect milder taste.

Are Grass-Fed Options Worth the Premium?

Yes, grass-fed can be worth the premium if you value leaner meat and more assertive, grassy flavors. You’ll notice thinner marbling, faster cooking, and sometimes stronger beef notes.

If you prioritize tenderness and juiciness, you might prefer grain-fed or a mix. Consider source, forage quality, and finishing practices.

For occasional indulgence, try a grass-fed option from a trusted supplier to compare with your usual cuts. It’s a nice way to see what the fuss is about without committing fully.

Do Orders Include Dry-Aging or Wet-Aging Details?

Yes, most orders include either dry-aging or wet-aging details, so you’ll know exactly how the steak was treated. You’ll see aging notes right on product pages or checkout, often with times like 14 to 28 days. You’ll feel the difference in flavor and tenderness as you bite in.

If it isn’t listed, you can always ask support to confirm the aging method before you buy. Either way, you’ll savor the process.

How Do I Thaw and Cook Mail-Order Steaks Properly?

To thaw and cook mail-order steaks properly, start by thawing them in the fridge for about 24 hours per inch of thickness. This slow thaw helps keep the meat safe and tender.

Once thawed, pat the steaks dry with paper towels and season generously. Let them sit out at room temperature for about 30 minutes before cooking. This helps them cook more evenly.

Next, heat a pan until it’s really hot and add a little oil. Sear the steaks for 2 to 3 minutes on each side for medium-rare. If the steaks are thick, you can finish cooking them in a 400°F oven to your desired doneness.

After cooking, let the steaks rest for 5 to 10 minutes before slicing. Resting helps keep all those delicious juices inside. For best results, use a meat thermometer to check the internal temperature.

Conclusion

Think of picking mail-order steaks like tending a forest of flavors. Each cutoff valley of a package holds a potential fire that can warm your dinner plans or spark a quiet Sunday feast.

Choose a path that matches your appetite, from tender Filets to bold NY Strips, and trust the journey from order to sizzle. With careful picks, your kitchen becomes a confident ranger guiding a campfire toward satisfying, reliable meals—seasoned, shared, and always worth the trek.

When it comes to enjoying premium beef at home, these 12 best mail-order steaks you won’t regret ordering bring convenience and quality straight to your doorstep.

• Author
• Recent Posts

Michael Davis

Founder at Grill Gusto

I'm Michael R. Davis, the grilling fanatic behind GrillGusto.com. After getting my first grill in college 15 years ago, I was hooked and have been perfecting my barbecue skills ever since. When I'm not developing new recipes for the site, you can find me in my backyard grilling up juicy steaks, smoking tender ribs, and experimenting with rubs and grill setups. I created GrillGusto to share my passion for the art of grilling. Let's get grillin'!

Latest posts by Michael Davis (see all)

• 15 Best Cordless Electric Fillet Knives for 2026 - February 13, 2026
• 15 Best Commercial Fillet Knives for 2026 - February 13, 2026
• 15 Best Cleaver Knives for Vegetables in 2026 - February 13, 2026